We Tested The Top Rated Under Eye Concealers


(funky hip hop music) – Last night, I didn’t sleep much. I think the whole point
was that we look tired. – Yes.
– I know I look tired. Thank you. – This is Clinique, and I
feel like I hear nothing but good things about Clinique. – Clinique was my first
makeup I ever got as a child. Not a child, that sounds weird. – It already feels like
some nice texture here. – Mmm.
– Mmm. – Ooh, this is real gooey. – Mmm, the texture. – Is that good, I can’t. – The coverage, I actually gave it a one. – Does this look like it did anything? – I put a big ‘ol glob under my eyes, and really smoothed it in there, and I see purple still. – But it just kind of
felt a lot more sticky. – See, I think I just
need something thicker ’cause my under eye is real blue. – We’re trying NYX Photogenic. Felt very smooth and light. – Look at the difference. – [Co-host] Whoa, that is incredible. – It’s a perfect amount of coverage, where it doesn’t look cakey, but it’s also not so sheer that
I have to do multiple coats. – For coverage, I gave it a four. – Fives are big deal for me. I just don’t throw around fives. – [Amy] For blending,
I also gave it a four. – Four for coverage and
then a five for blending. – [Co-host] She does
not give fives easily! – I know, I know. This is a big deal. – This is a commitment. – Very natural. NYX. – I’d be interested to
see if this one lasts throughout the day, or if it turns into those
little canyons of coverup. – [Daysha] The list is Revlon PhotoReady. – I love Revlon liquid concealer. – It feels a little thicker. – Ooh, I don’t know about that. – Yeah, this is a weird feeling. – I’m not liking the texture of it. I feels like it’s very dry. There’s not enough moisture, and coverage, I gave it a three. – I’m really hoping for more. Maybe this just isn’t for my skin. Maybe my skin is real weird. – So, I gave the coverage a three. I felt like it was adequate. – I don’t hate it. And it gets a lot of points in my heart because it’s cheap. – The next we have is NARS. It says Radiant Creamy Concealer, so that is a very high expectations. – I better be glowing up in this bitch.
– Mm-hmm. – NARS, this one everyone
is talking about. – It’s really soft, and
you can immediately feel the difference.
– Ooh, yeah. – Yeah, it feels very creamy. – Oh, this is a squishy brush. – Yeah, it does. – Yeah, that looks good. Yeah. – Maybe this might be
worth the money after all. – So, the NARS is a little
thicker than the NYX. I think it has incredible coverage. It’s smooth. It looks good. The only thing that I’m not
feeling is it’s a little thick. I feel like the NARS is more for someone, who wears makeup, like full foundation. – I just went five
’cause those were all in. It felt really nice,
I like the applicator. I like the color. – My winner is the NYX. – So, my winner is the NARS. We gotta test it out. – It’s NYX. NYX! NYX! – Real moment, I can’t tell the difference between any of ’em. (women laughing) (funky hip hop music)

100 comments

  1. I cringed so hard every time they called it N.Y.X. instead of NYX. How did none of them know that they were pronouncing it wrong?!

  2. Whaaat I didn't think Sierra worked for Buzzfeed anymore, I haven't seen her in any videos in at least a year.

  3. NYX has a specific concealer to cover up under eye bags. Not the just the regular one tested here. Check it out, it's my saving grace after sleepless nights!

  4. only one of those girls really hard dark circles. like c'mon, at least put people who really have that problem.

  5. They need to get people like Kelsey for these kinds of videos because these girls clearly wear a very small amount of makeup and don't really know what they're talking about, they didn't even pronounce NYX correctly… also angry shape tape wasn't in this like ???

  6. I use a NYX foundation stick for my concealer, and it works wonders. Its a bit thick, so blending isn't the best, but the coverage is great.

  7. I'm sure that Sierra chick is a peach in person, but every video she is in she acts SO fake. Like she either has to play it up for the camera or she acts like a child who's parent is filming their audition tape for the next reality show. Calm the eff down.

  8. well if u keep swiping instead of tapping u will never get some coverage!!! u just taking of and spreading it everywhere when u need it in specific places (sorry my bad english tho)

  9. "top rated" literally 90% of the people who put money into makeup swear on shape-tape. do some better research, like idk, click on a different channel's youtube video?

  10. Its nice to hear opinions from average people who dont obsess and spend all their free time (and money) on makeup related things, like moi.

  11. I came back to say: THANK YOU for these reviews! I picked up the NYX product at work and it's been fantastic! And it seems to last well the whole day with my finishing powder!

  12. Nars will forever be my favorite concealer. I have extremely pale skin and the chantilly shade matches perfectly, blends well, and has great coverage!

  13. I feel that if you do videos like this and want to properly represent the product + its effects, you'd need better lighting and a more controlled angle for each test shot. In more than half of these the before always looks better than the after just because of the lighting and odd angles you choose for all the comparisons. You'd think that as professionals, the basics would be really solid for this kind of video. I'm a bit disappointed.

  14. Scientists say that sleep deprivation has the same side effects as inebriation…yeah I can definitely see that from this video LOL

  15. rubs under eye 5000 times and removes all concealer
    YAH the coverage is just so bad it didn't do a difference….I love you guys but come on you dont put on concealer like eye cream and rub it everywhere

  16. They didn't even have dark circles… but for me, bye bye under eye with mattifying powder bc it's super shiny but the coverage is great

  17. They're not even using the Clinique "Beyond Perfecting" concealer they mentioned. The packaging is clearly a completely different formula "line-smoothing" concealer.

  18. Tarte shape and tape is THE BEST concealer. It is a little expensive but TBH one of the best concealers I have ever used and I ton of people that I know use it and love it!! Definitely check it out if you have bad under eyes!!! (Edit) it has a lot of different shades

  19. Nars is the only concealer I've ever used that stays put all day, covers my alarmingly dark circles, and blends well enough with my skin that I can wear it with nothing but a light dusting of powder on my face.

  20. Finally tested by women who actually have dark circles. Whenever I see this type of videos it's always people with no bags what so ever

  21. I was really surprised that the shape tape from tarte and the fit me concealer from maybellene weren't shown. They're always being hyped up and they're really good.

  22. Lol! This video his hilarious. I use Tarte Concealer. Not sure why the ladies didn't fill in the concealer with a shape. Swiping doesn't conceal. They all may conceal well, but their method messed it up.

  23. This video should be called "We tested one top rated under eye concealer and three other ones you might have heard about"

    Everyone saying N-Y-X is giving me flashbacks to 2008 when no one knew how to pronounce NYX.

  24. I use L'Oréal concealer it is good for me cuz I'm pale so i don't need a dark shade but you need setting powder for it or at the end of the day you have so many creases

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *